Enter your search text in the box above

Select a result to preview

Shareholder Primacy (Milton Friedman)

#business #finance #corporate-governance #shareholders #business-ethics #economics
Summary

Shareholder Primacy (also called the Friedman Doctrine) is the corporate governance principle that a corporation's sole responsibility is to maximize profits for its shareholders. It was most famously articulated by economist Milton Friedman in a 1970 New York Times Magazine article.

The Friedman Doctrine

In his landmark 1970 article "The Social Responsibility of Business is to Increase its Profits", Milton Friedman argued:

"There is one and only one social responsibility of business — to use its resources and engage in activities designed to increase its profits so long as it stays within the rules of the game, which is to say, engages in open and free competition without deception or fraud."

Key Arguments

  1. Agency Logic: Corporate executives are employees of the shareholders. Spending shareholder money on social causes is a form of taxation without representation — the executive is spending someone else's money for someone else's benefit.

  2. Comparative Advantage: Business leaders are not experts in solving social problems. Letting them decide which social causes to support is inefficient and undemocratic. Social issues should be addressed by government and individuals, not corporations.

  3. Legal Foundation: In Anglo-American corporate law, directors owe fiduciary duties to the corporation and its shareholders. Pursuing non-profit objectives at the expense of profits could be a breach of those duties.

  4. Market Discipline: Companies that pursue social goals at the expense of profits will be outcompeted by those that focus on profit maximization, ultimately harming everyone.

Historical Context

Rise in the 1970s–80s

Shareholder primacy gained dominance alongside:

The Dodge v. Ford Case (1919)

A foundational legal precedent. Henry Ford wanted to reinvest profits to lower prices and benefit employees. Shareholders sued. The Michigan Supreme Court ruled that a business is organized primarily for the profit of its stockholders, stating:

"A business corporation is organized and carried on primarily for the profit of the stockholders. The powers of the directors are to be employed for that end."

Criticisms

Criticism Argument
Short-termism Maximizing quarterly earnings undermines long-term investment in R&D, employees, and infrastructure.
Externalities Profits can be maximized by imposing costs on society (pollution, unsafe products, labor exploitation).
Rising inequality The focus on shareholder returns has correlated with stagnating wages and growing wealth concentration.
Legal evolution Benefit corporation statutes and stakeholder governance laws (e.g., UK Companies Act 2006 s.172) have eroded the strict primacy model.

The Shift Away from Primacy

Several developments have challenged shareholder primacy in the 21st century:

Relationship to Other Concepts

References